John Deere 510 P-Tier vs Bobcat E165 Large Excavators
Compare the John Deere 510 P-Tier and Bobcat E165 large excavators to see which machine delivers better digging power, control, and durability for large-scale excavation jobs. This detailed comparison breaks down engine performance, lift capacity, hydraulics, and operator comfort to help you make the right investment for your operation.
The John Deere 510 P-Tier is a production-class large excavator designed for heavy-duty digging, site prep, and high-volume material handling. Powered by a high-output diesel engine, it delivers strong swing torque, fast cycle times, and high hydraulic flow for demanding conditions. The Bobcat E165, while slightly smaller, offers class-leading precision, fuel efficiency, and refined control in tight spaces. These two machines serve different scales of work, but both offer rugged reliability and performance features built for serious contractors.
John Deere 510 P-Tier Pros:
High horsepower engine delivers superior swing torque and digging force
Durable undercarriage built for extreme site conditions
Powerful hydraulic system with fast cycle times
Spacious cab with customizable controls and seat suspension
Excellent lift capacity for large pipe, rock, and material handling
John Deere 510 P-Tier Cons:
Larger footprint requires more clearance and transport support
Higher fuel consumption under full load
Not ideal for tight, confined job sites
Bobcat E165 Pros:
Compact frame for better mobility on tight job sites
Advanced hydraulic control for precision work
Lower fuel consumption with smart power modes
Comfortable operator station with intuitive joystick controls
Excellent visibility and easy access maintenance layout
Bobcat E165 Cons:
Less horsepower and digging force than Deere 510
Not built for extreme mass excavation tasks
Smaller undercarriage can limit stability with heavy loads
Bobcat vs. John Deere 510 P-Tier:
The 510 P-Tier is built for high-production digging, large-scale earthmoving, and bulk material applications. It's ideal for contractors who need the most power, reach, and lift. The Bobcat E165 is suited for contractors who prioritize fuel savings, jobsite agility, and control in tighter environments. Choose John Deere for brute force and productivity. Choose Bobcat for refined operation and compact power.