John Deere 17 P-Tier vs. Bobcat E10 Compact Excavators
Compare the John Deere 17 P-Tier and Bobcat E10 compact excavators to determine which offers superior performance, maneuverability, and operator comfort for your construction or landscaping needs. This side-by-side analysis highlights key differences in engine power, operating weight, and hydraulic capabilities to help you choose the best compact excavator for your projects.
The John Deere 17 P-Tier is a compact excavator designed for efficient operation in tight spaces. With a 14.5-hp engine and a maximum digging depth of 7 ft. 2 in., it offers reliable performance for landscaping, agriculture, and general construction applications. The Bobcat E10, equipped with a 10.2-hp engine and a digging depth of 6 ft., provides a slightly lighter alternative with advanced features for enhanced operator comfort and versatility.
John Deere 17 P-Tier Pros:
14.5-hp engine delivers strong performance for demanding tasks
Operating weight of 3,790 lb. allows for handling heavy loads
Maximum digging depth of 7 ft. 2 in. provides excellent reach
Spacious, comfortable operator station with ergonomic controls
Variable-width undercarriage enhances maneuverability in tight spaces
John Deere 17 P-Tier Cons:
Higher operating weight may impact fuel efficiency
Larger footprint may be less suitable for extremely confined areas
Standard features may require additional options for enhanced performance
Bobcat E10 Pros:
10.2-hp engine offers reliable performance in a compact design
Operating weight of 2,593 lb. for handling substantial loads
Maximum digging depth of 6 ft. for deep excavation tasks
Zero tail swing design allows for operation in tight spaces
Retractable undercarriage and foldable ROPS enhance versatility
Bobcat E10 Cons:
Lower horsepower compared to John Deere 17 P-Tier
Smaller fuel tank may require more frequent refueling
Standard features may require additional options for enhanced performance
Bobcat vs. John Deere 17 P-Tier:
The John Deere 17 P-Tier is ideal for operators who need higher lift capacity and a spacious cab for extended use, making it suitable for heavy-duty applications. The Bobcat E10, with its compact size and advanced hydraulic options, is better suited for jobsites with limited space and tasks requiring precise maneuverability. Choose the 17 P-Tier for greater lifting power and operator comfort; opt for the E10 for enhanced agility and hydraulic performance.